HR Jetpack
Home / HR Courses / Employment Law 101 / Hiring Process / The Economic Realities Test

Lesson:

The Economic Realities Test

  • Course: Employment Law 101
  • Module: Hiring Process
  • Lesson Type: Video
  • Lesson Duration: 7:22

Lesson Transcript

We're going to start by thinking about how workers in the workplace are categorized. Are they going to be employee use or are they going to be independent contractors? This is an area that you have to be very careful with when you're dealing with a workforce. How do you designate it? There's a number of reasons. An employee receives benefits. When I say benefits, they receive workers' compensation benefits through the business. They receive unemployment benefits and there may be other benefits depending upon your state your jurisdiction. Also, the employer is obligated to pay a number of state and federal taxes depending on your jurisdiction as well.

Contrast that with an independent contractor. An independent contractor, when they're paid money they have to pay their own taxes out of it. It's not done for them like an employer would. In addition, an independent contractor is responsible for their own workers compensation and unemployment insurance benefits amongst other differences so for these reasons classifying your workforce is important.

Misclassification of a worker as an independent contractor when they should be employees in those benefits being taken from the employer to pay for these various benefits with our government is an area that creates a lot of liability for businesses.

The Fair Labor Standards Act is a federal law enacted in 1938 that deals with how people are paid and in that law is the main area in which we look at the definition of employee from a statutory perspective. An employee must have an employment relationship with the business and to be employed means to, and this is the way it's worded, to suffer or permit to work. Now courts have interpreted that phrase very, very broadly and ultimately, it has to do with whether those workers are economically dependent upon the business so that's what we're looking for when we think about the test that's used by most courts and that is called the economic realities test.

So the economic realities test ultimately looks at a lot of issues. One is how integral is the work that the independent contractor, the worker, does. How integral is that the employer's business. If you owned a restaurant and you hired me to clean the carpets. And I came in once a month to clean the carpets and you paid an invoice and I had my own business. I provided my own chemicals. I came whenever I wanted during the month to make sure at the end of the month they were looking wonderful and you were happy. Then likely the work that I'm doing is not integral to your business because it is just a part of the fixtures which you're in the business for in the way you identify your restaurant is service quality food right and maybe environment to some extent but lesser. Well, if instead you hired me as a cook to go in between eight and five and prep all of these food products in a way that you direct, then likely I am not an independent contractor because of the degree of control and the fact that being a cook is integral to my business. Much more than the idea of some guy that's cleaning carpet. Also, what about managerial skills? If I'm the guy who's cleaning the carpets I could go to other restaurants and clean their carpets or other businesses I can make decisions on what types of chemicals I should use to get the best results and be most cost effective. An employer dealing with an employee generally doesn't give those types of skills to the employee instead, if I'm prepping in the kitchen, you're telling me what foods to prep, how much to prep and how to prep it so it's a much different relationship. Also, if I'm your cook, you have made an investment in my training, in the equipment I use, in the kitchen facilities you give me. But all of that doesn't exist with the guy that's cleaning the carpets for the restaurant so it's a different analysis altogether.

Do the skills and initiatives demonstrate independent judgment? Well, we're not give me your tremendous agree of independent judgment as the employee but we may give you significant independent judgment because all we're managing for independent contractors is the end result, a clean carpet. That's all I want. I don't care how you do it. I'm not going to schedule it as long as it doesn't conflict with my business but I need it cleaned and I need it to look good consistently and if you meet that result then you don't have a problem with the business.

Another aspect of it is permanency. And you look at the carpet cleaner can go clean carpets for several different places but we may not want the guy that we have coming in eight to five working with other restaurants. So those types of decisions are part of the analysis as well. Really the key is the how much control you're exercising over the business.

You know is, is the business dictating training? Is it dictating procedures? Processes? Time? Is it providing specialized equipment in controlling the type of equipment you use and how you use it? And if the answer to those questions are yes then likely you're dealing with an employee as opposed to an independent contractor.

You know there are several instances where a business will create something like a contract, an independent contractor agreement but they don't treat the worker as an independent contractor. They treat them as an employee. The exercise significant control over the process rather than the result and if you have a signed agreement but you're treating them like employees, the fact that you have a signed agreement is not going to carry the day. It's essentially going to be inconsequential. Even if you call them independent contractors, the label in and of itself, isn't part of the analysis. The analysis is, how they're managed, how they're treated, what the resources are. Things of that nature.

Sometimes you'll have a guy who cleans your rug, create a company name and he has incorporated a business. Now, certainly that's important and that can be a factor in the analysis. But in the economic realities test, we're not really looking at that as much as we are from a economic perspective is that worker so entrenched with this business, that he's economically dependent and that's the reality.

Also how are they paid? If you're giving me an invoice and I’m paying you within thirty days, that's a lot different than if I'm paying you every two weeks like the other like the rest of the people that are working that we're calling employees. So all of these factors are important to think about.

Mark Addington

Instructor:

Mark Addington

Mark A. Addington, Esq. advises and advocates on behalf of businesses concerning Labor & Employment Law, Business Regulatory Compliance, Restrictive Covenants (Non-Competition, Non-Solicitation, and Confidentiality), Wage & Hour, Privacy, Technology,...

Mark's Full Bio

HR Courses

Human Resources Training Programs

Self-paced HR Courses

The following HR courses are self-paced (asynchronous), and qualify for both SHRM and HRCI recertification credits. These courses are included in the HR Recertification Subscription.

Effective Disciplinary Action Policies and Procedures

Duration: 1 hr 1 min
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Liz LaForte

Liz LaForte

RFP Process for HR

Duration: 1 hr 19 mins
SHRM: 1.25 PDC
HRCI: 1.25 General

Mark Fogel

Mark Fogel

Organizational Ethics for HR Managers

Duration: 1 hr 30 mins
SHRM: 1.5 PDC
HRCI: 1.5 General

Dawn Tedesco

Dawn Tedesco

HR as a Business Partner

Duration: 1 hr 5 min
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Scott Pitts

Scott Pitts

Blockchain for HR

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Michael Wilson

Michael Wilson

HR Strategic Planning

Duration: 1 hr 2 mins
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Hayley Buonopane

Hayley Buonopane

Employee Engagement & Retention

Duration: 1 hr 4 mins
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Hayley Buonopane

Hayley Buonopane

HR Metrics That Matter

Duration: 1 hr 16 mins
SHRM: 1.25 PDC
HRCI: 1.25 Business

Christina Danforth

Christina Danforth

Finance for Absolute Beginners

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Anna Samorukova

Anna Samorukova

Change Management 101

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Hayley Buonopane

Hayley Buonopane

Labor Relations

Duration: 1 hr 42 mins
SHRM: 1.50 PDC
HRCI: 1.75 General

Matthew Kerzner

Matthew Kerzner

Diversity and Inclusion

Duration: 1 hr 25 mins
SHRM: 1.25 PDC
HRCI: 1.50 General

Christina Danforth

Christina Danforth

HR Analytics

Duration: 1 hr 31 mins
SHRM: 1.50 PDC
HRCI: 1.50 Business

Christina Danforth

Christina Danforth

Performance Management: Development & Deployment

Duration: 1 hr 18 mins
SHRM: 1.25 PDC
HRCI: 1.25 General

Christina Danforth

Christina Danforth

The Role Assessments Play in Talent Management

Duration: 2 hr 5 mins
SHRM: 2.0 PDC
HRCI: 2.0 General

Craig Haas

Craig Haas

AI for HR

Duration: 1 hr 3 mins
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Michael Wilson

Michael Wilson

Compensation 101

Duration: 1 hr 8 mins
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.25 General

Pamela Sande

Pamela Sande

Effective Leadership Communications for HR Professionals

Duration: 2 hr 30 mins
SHRM: 2.5 PDC
HRCI: 2.5 General

Christina Danforth

Christina Danforth

Recruiting Strategies to Hire the Best Candidate

Duration: 1 hr 6 mins
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Lois Krause

Lois Krause

Cybersecurity 101 for HR Pros

Duration: 1 hr 2 mins
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Michael Wilson

Michael Wilson

EQ Competence: Fostering a Talent Advantage that Drives Organizational Performance

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Craig Haas

Craig Haas

Thinking Lean

Duration: 1 hr 8 mins
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.25 Business

Christina Danforth

Christina Danforth

Coaching for HR Professionals

Duration: 1 hr 2 mins
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Stacey Zackin

Stacey Zackin

The Employment Cycle

Duration: 1 hr 45 mins
SHRM: 1.75 PDC
HRCI: 1.75 General

Christina Danforth

Christina Danforth

Behavioral and Situational Interviewing

Duration: 1 hr 8 mins
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.25 General

Stephanie Legatos

Stephanie Legatos

Dynamic Dialogues

Duration: 1 hr 10 mins
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.25 General

Stacey Zackin

Stacey Zackin

Employment Law 101

Duration: 3 hr 11 mins
SHRM: 3.0 PDC
HRCI: 3.25 General

Mark Addington

Mark Addington

Thrown to the Wolves: Preparing Your New Leaders to Lead the Pack

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Karen Hinds

Karen Hinds

Introduction to Organizational Development

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Hayley Buonopane

Hayley Buonopane

Practical Meeting Preparation: Getting Ready for a Productive Meeting

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Christine Gatti

Christine Gatti

Succession Planning: Build Your Bench

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Hayley Buonopane

Hayley Buonopane

Practices for Hiring Successfully

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Hayley Buonopane

Hayley Buonopane

Team Development: Building Collaboration & Effectiveness

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Christine Gatti

Christine Gatti

Leading and Managing the Need for Both

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Hayley Buonopane

Hayley Buonopane

Coaching: Guiding the Management Team

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Hayley Buonopane

Hayley Buonopane

Being A Change Agent

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Hayley Buonopane

Hayley Buonopane

Leading a Multigenerational Team

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Karen Hinds

Karen Hinds

Multi-Generational Workforce: Problem or Competitive Advantage?

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Christine Gatti

Christine Gatti

Virtual Reality: The Future of HR

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Christina Danforth

Christina Danforth

Unconscious Bias: Impact on Recruitment and Retention

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Christina Danforth

Christina Danforth

Business Fundamentals for HR Pros

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Jack Antonich

Jack Antonich

Influence and Communications as an HR Pro

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Stacey Zackin

Stacey Zackin

Value Based Decision Making for HR Pros

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Stacey Zackin

Stacey Zackin

Strategic Planning to Support HR Initiatives

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Dr. Deborah Osgood

Dr. Deborah Osgood

Meet in the Middle: Best Methods for Conflict Management

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Christine Gatti

Christine Gatti

Economics for HR Professionals

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Jack Antonich

Jack Antonich

Business Plans: Why HR Pros Should Care

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Jack Antonich

Jack Antonich

Emotional Intelligence: What is it and Why Does it Matter

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Christine Gatti

Christine Gatti

Marketing/Selling Continuum (From Idea to Revenue)

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Jack Antonich

Jack Antonich

Diversity Equity & Inclusion The Lens We Wear

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Stacey Zackin

Stacey Zackin

Welcome! What HR can Learn from the Field of Hospitality

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Stacey Zackin

Stacey Zackin

Accounting and Financial Reporting for HR Pros

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Jack Antonich

Jack Antonich

How HR Can Establish & Influence a Culture Of Hospitality

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Stacey Zackin

Stacey Zackin

Raising Capital (Who, What, When, Where, Why & How)

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 Business

Jack Antonich

Jack Antonich

Cultural Competence: Fostering Diversity Equity & Inclusion

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Stacey Zackin

Stacey Zackin

DiSC Communication Styles: What are They & How They can Help You

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Christine Gatti

Christine Gatti

Effective Meeting Facilitation for HR Pros

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Christine Gatti

Christine Gatti

Best Practices in Providing Effective Performance Feedback

Duration: 1 hr
SHRM: 1.0 PDC
HRCI: 1.0 General

Christine Gatti

Christine Gatti